American Accounting Association

The Future Viability of AAA Members' Programs

Report of the Changing Environment Committee

American Accounting Association
July 15, 1998

b) Demands in Business and Government
As the economy grows, the demand for accounting graduates in business and government continues to grow. However, the accountant's role in these sectors is rapidly changing. According to surveys by the Institute of Management Accountants and the AICPA Visioning Project, professional accountants are increasingly becoming internal consultants. They are increasingly visible in positions that combine finance, systems, and accounting knowledge and skills to provide information to line managers to aid their decisions. There are fewer formal training programs for new graduates and more emphasis on learning on the job. New graduates are expected to be productive immediately in positions that require much more than technical accounting knowledge. The GAO recently observed (GAO, 1998):

"In the past, the accounting function was paper-driven, human resource intensive, and clerical in nature. In many organizations today, recent advances in information technology, as well as competitive pressures and corporate restructuring, have combined to dramatically change the accounting function from a clerical to an analytical and consultative focus."

Finding positions in business and government is more complex than finding jobs in public accounting. The large public accounting firms have organized recruiting programs because they hire many accountants every year. Many business and government organizations do not hire enough accountants to make such a recruiting program worthwhile. Thus, networking and other less formal job search techniques often are needed by students to find a good match between them and a company. In such a market, internships are playing a much more important role than ever in matching graduates with companies. At some universities and in some companies, the number of career placements that develop out of internships exceeds the number developed through other recruiting strategies.

Another trend in business is the downsizing of finance departments, which is the entry point where most accounting graduates are hired. As routine accounting functions are increasingly automated, the need for employees with technical accounting skills but nothing else to offer has dwindled. Companies are looking for analysts, someone who can help make sense of accounting numbers, not just produce the accounting numbers. The budgets of almost all finance departments of major companies have decreased as a percentage of sales over the last decade, partly as a result of outsourcing of routine accounting functions. This trend continues. Like public accounting, the accounting positions that are disappearing in industry are those narrowly focused on technical accounting. The primary growth area is for accountants who can help managers better understand and use information for decision making.

With the growth of intranets, where managers can have direct access to databases, the demand for accountants extends into two additional areas: a) designing and maintaining the accounting systems and related security and controls; and b) helping managers find and use information from data warehouses contained in the intranet. This meansthat graduates with accounting knowledge and skills that are coupled with either systems expertise or financial analysis skills will be in high demand.

Non-Traditional Deliverers
Non-traditional deliverers, which include corporate and for-profit universities, are rapidly establishing a presence in the market for post-secondary education. The fastest growing sector of post-secondary education is the corporate university (Traub, 1997). In the late 1980's only a few corporate universities existed; by 1994, the number had grown to over 400; today there are over 1000 (Moore, 1997). To house these new corporate learners on a college campus, thirteen universities the size of Harvard would have to be built to handle a single year's growth in enrollment. Corporate education is currently growing 100 times faster (i.e., 10,000 percent faster) than traditional university education (Davis and Botkin, 1994). Some of this corporate education is not competing with university education, e.g., remedial instruction involving basic skills in reading, writing, and math job-related skills that are not generic (e.g., McDonald's kitchen skills), and some CPE courses which are narrowly focused on particular industry issues. However, much of the education provided today by corporate universities does in fact compete directly with university instruction.

Corporate universities are being established mainly by large corporations. Davis and Botkin (1994) profile a large number of such corporate universities, including those of Arthur Andersen, Motorola, Federal Express, Corning, Microsoft, IBM, General Motors, General Electric, AT&T, McDonalds, Hart Schaffner & Marx, and Holiday Inn.

A second group of new deliverers are the "for-profit" universities exemplified by the University of Phoenix, which is now the largest for-profit university in the United States. In the last decade, when most traditional universities experienced flat enrollments, Phoenix grew from 3,000 to 40,000 students (Traub, 1997). It is presently growing at the rate of 20 per cent per year ("The New U," 1998).

Recently, cable entrepreneur Glenn Jones created College Connection, which offers students Internet access to inexpensive degree programs from 13 institutions. College Connections now has 7,000 students and is growing at a rate of 30 per cent per year ("The New U," 1998). Other for-profits include Ottawa University, a Kansas institution with campuses in Arizona, Singapore, Malaysia, and Hong Kong (Traub, 1997); and the Open University head-quartered in the UK and serving the UK and Europe (Open University, 1997). Additionally, in 1997, Michael Milken (junk bond king) and Lawrence Ellison (Oracle Chairman) formed Knowledge Universe, a for-profit education company that is aiming to take a $10 billion slice of the education market from toys to advanced degrees ("The New U," 1998).

Back Continue...

[Executive Summary] [Appendix] [Bibliography]

Back to Committee Reports